Submit your paper : editorIJETjournal@gmail.com

Paper Title : Review of Literature Regarding Progressive Collapse of WTC Twin Towers – A Call for Re-evaluation (Updated Version 2)

ISSN : 2395-1303
Year of Publication : 2022
10.5281/zenodo.7062258

Authors: Adam Taylor, B.Sc

         


Abstract
Since the tragic events of September 11th, 2001, the official view endorsed by the National Institute of Standards and Technology is that the Twin Towers of the WTC complex suffered a “progressive collapse,” wherein the upper sections crushed the lower floors as they pancaked all the way to the ground. This general scenario has become the de facto explanation for the collapse of the Towers, supported by the majority of the engineering community. However, a review of relevant literature on the collapses casts significant doubt on this scenario, showing that a progressive collapse model would have resulted in a longer time to collapse, or perhaps a collapse that would not have progressed at all. As such, re-evaluation of the collapses and development of other, more plausible models is needed.

Reference
Anonymous and F. Legge (2009), “Falsifiability and the NIST WTC Report: A Study in Theoretical Adequacy,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 29. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Bažant, Z., J.-L. Lee, F. Greening, and D. Benson (2008), “What Did and Did Not Cause Collapse of World Trade Center Twin Towers in New York?,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 134(10): 892-906. Bažant, Z., and M. Verdure (2007), “Mechanics of Progressive Collapse: Learning from World Trade Center and Building Demolitions,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 133(3): 308-319. Bažant, Z., and Y. Zhou (2002), “Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse? – Simple Analysis,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 128(1): 2-6. Addendum 128(3): 369-370. Chandler, D. (2010a), “Destruction of the World Trade Center North Tower and Fundamental Physics,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 28. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. — (2010b) “What a Gravity-Driven Demolition Looks Like.” Online at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NiHeCjZlkr8. — (2019), “Idealized Pancake Theory Collapse Time.” Online at http://www.scientistsfor911truth.com/wp- content/uploads/2019/01/IdealizedPancakeCollapseCalcs.pdf. Cherepanov, G. (2005), “September 11 and Fracture Mechanics – A Retrospective,” International Journal of Fracture 132: L25-L26. — (2006a), “On the Collapse of the World Trade Center Towers on September 11, 2001,” Вестник СамГ – Естественнонаучная серия 2(42): 74-91. — (2006b), “Mechanics of the WTC collapse,” International Journal of Fracture 141: 287-289. — (2008), “Collapse of Towers as Applied to September 11 Events,” Material Science 44(4): 489-499. Cherepanov, G., and I. Esparragoza (2007), “Progressive Collapse of Towers: The Resistance Effect,” International Journal of Fracture 143: 203-206. Craighead, G. (2009), High-Rise Security and Fire Life Safety, 3rd ed., New York: Elsevier. Denny, M. (2010), “How Fast Does a Building Fall?,” European Journal of Physics 31(4): 943-948. Douglas, E. (2006), “The NIST WTC Investigation – How Real Was The Simulation?,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 6. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Eagar, T., and C. Musso (2001), “Why Did the World Trade Center Collapse? Science, Engineering, and Speculation,” JOM 53(12): 8-11. Online at https://www.tms.org/pubs/journals/jom/0112/ eagar/eagar-0112.html. Eastman, T., and J. Cole (2013), “WTC Destruction: An Analysis of Peer Reviewed Technical Literature 2001—2012,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 37. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. FEMA (2002a), “World Trade Center Building Performance Study (Chapter 8).” Online at https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/ fema403_ch8.pdf — (2002b) “World Trade Center Building Performance Study (Appendix A).” Online at https://www.fema.gov/pdf/library/ fema403_apa.pdf. Glover, N. (2002), “Collapse Lessons,” Fire Engineering, pp. 97-104. Grabbe, C. (2010), “Discussion of ‘Progressive Collapse of the World Trade Center: Simple Analysis’ by K.A. Seffen,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 136(4): 538-539. Greening, F. (2006), “To whom it may concern,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 2. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Jones, S., R. Korol, A. Szamboti, and T. Walter (2016), “15 Years Later: On the Physics of High-Rise Building Collapses,” Europhysics News 47(4): 21-26. Korol, R., K. Sivakumaran, and F. Greening (2011), “Collapse Time Analysis of Multi-Story Structural Steel Buildings,” The Open Civil Engineering Journal 5: 25-35. Korol, R., and T. Szamboti (2017), “A Response from the ‘Lay Critics’ Regarding ‘Mechanics-Based Mathematical Studies Proving Spontaneity of Post-Impact WTC Towers Collapse.’” Online at https://www.ae911truth.org. Kuttler, K. (2007), “Collapse Time Calculations for WTC 1,” Journal of 9/11 Studies. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Le, J.-L., and Z. Bažant (2011), “Why the Observed Motion History of World Trade Center Towers Is Smooth,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 137(1): 82-84. — (2017), “Mechanics-Based Mathematical Studies Proving Sponta-neity of Post-Impact WTC Towers Collapse” Europhysics News 48(1): 18-23. — (2022), “Spontaneous Collapse Mechanism of World Trade Center Twin Towers and Progressive Collapse in General,” Journal of Structural Engineering 148(6). MacQueen, G., and T. Szamboti (2009), “The Missing Jolt: A Simple Refutation of the NIST-Bazant Collapse Hypothesis,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 24. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. McIlvaine, B., B. Doyle, S. Jones, K. Ryan, R. Gage, and F. Legge (2007), “9/11 Family Members and Scholars: Request for Correction Submitted to NIST,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 12. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Mitteldorf, J. (2018), “How Did the Three WTC Towers Fall? A Minimum Time for ‘Pancaking’ Collapse.” Online at https:// scientistsfor911truth.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Min_Time_for_Pancaking.pdf. Němec, I., M. Juráňová, I. Ševčík, P. Frantík, and Z. Vlk (2012), “Dynamics of Collapse of a High Building,” Journal of Mechanics Engineering and Automation 2: 349-354. Němec, I., M. Trcala, J. Vala, and A. Vaněčková (2018), “A Contribution to Analysis of Collapse of High-Rise Building Inspired by the Collapses of WTC1 and WTC2: Derivation of Simple Formulas for Collapse Upper Speed and Acceleration,” Journal of Applied Mathematics and Physics 6: 2666-2680. NIST (2005a), NCSTAR 1. Online at https://www.nist.gov/el/final-reports-nist-world-trade-center-disaster-investigation. — (2005b), NCSTAR 1-3. Online at https://www.nist.gov/el/final-reports-nist-world-trade-center-disaster-investigation. — (2005c), NCSTAR 1-6. Online at https://www.nist.gov/el/final-reports-nist-world-trade-center-disaster-investigation. — (2005d), NCSTAR 1-6D. Online at https://www.nist.gov/el/final-reports-nist-world-trade-center-disaster-investigation. — (2011), “Questions and Answers about the NIST WTC Towers Investigation.” Online at https://www.nist.gov/world-trade-center-investigation/study-faqs/wtc-towers-investigation. Pluvinage, G., and A. Sedmak (2009), Security and Reliability of Damaged Structures and Defective Materials, Netherlands: Springer. Rapp, R. (1964), “The World Trade Center: An Architectural and Engineering Milestone,” Contemporary Steel Design 1(4). Ross, G. (2006a), “Momentum Transfer Analysis of the Collapse of the Upper Storeys of WTC 1,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 1. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. — (2006b), “Reply to Dr. Greening,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 2. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Schneider, A. (2019), “The Structural Dynamics of the World Trade Center Catastrophe,” IABSE New York City, The Evolving Metropolis, Congress Report 114: 2151-2156. Online at https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.10801. Seffen, K. (2008), “Progressive Collapse of the World Trade Center: Simple Analysis,” Journal of Engineering Mechanics 132(2): 125-132. Szuladziński, G. (2012), “Temporal Considerations in Collapse of WTC Towers,” International Journal of Structural Engineering 3(3): 189-207. Szuladziński, G., A. Szamboti, and R. Johns (2013), “Some Misunderstandings Related to WTC Collapse Analysis,” International Journal of Protective Structures 4(2): 117-126. Taylor, A. (2022), “Review of Literature Regarding Progressive Collapse of WTC Twin Towers – A Call for Re-evaluation,” International Journal of Engineering and Techniques 8(2): 45-54. Urich, G. (2007), “Analysis of the Mass and Potential Energy of World Trade Center Tower 1,” Journal of 9/11 Studies 18. Online at http://www.journalof911studies.com. Yarlagadda, T., H. Hajiloo, L. Jiang, M. Green, and A. Usmani (2018), “Preliminary Modelling of Plasco Tower Collapse,” International Journal of High-Rise Buildings 7(4): 397-408.
Keywords
— Pancake collapse, Progressive collapse, WTC, September 11th